The Wonderful World of Online Jewelry Stores

Looking to add a touch of elegance to your wardrobe without breaking the bank? We've curated a list of 24 exceptional online jewelry stores that offer a stunning selection of fine jewelry at prices that won't drain your wallet. Indulge in the opulent world of jewelry with these handpicked stores, where their intricate designs, high-quality craftsmanship, and affordable price tags come together to create a harmonious shopping experience. From delicate necklaces to sparkling rings and everything in between, you'll find something to suit every occasion and style. Each of these online jewelry stores has earned its place on our list by offering impeccable customer service, secure transactions, and a diverse range of collections that cater to different tastes and budgets. Whether you prefer timeless classics or contemporary trends, these stores have something for everyone. Prepare to be mesmerized as you explore the refined collections these jewelry stores have to offer. Discover dazzling diamonds, radiant gemstones, and elegant gold and silver pieces that are sure to turn heads and make a statement. With a wide array of options, you're guaranteed to find jewelry that reflects your unique personality and enhances your natural beauty. Shop with confidence, knowing that these online jewelry stores prioritize authenticity and use only ethically sourced materials. This ensures that the pieces you invest in not only enhance your personal style but also contribute to a sustainable and responsible fashion industry. So, are you ready to delve into the world of affordable fine jewelry? Let these 24 online jewelry stores be your guide, and unlock a treasure trove of beauty and elegance that will elevate your fashion game to new heights.

24 top online stores for affordable fine jewelry

Ana Luisa Necklace and Awe Inspired Necklace

Whether you’re on the hunt for delicate pieces or bold statement jewelry, the world of fine jewelry can be an intimidating place. With its inaccessible prices, confusing technical jargon, and mysterious production methods, it’s no wonder we feel overwhelmed. But fear not! The times are changing, and direct-to-consumer jewelry companies have arrived to save the day. These online jewelry stores offer affordable prices without sacrificing quality, making it easier than ever to find pieces that meet all our criteria.

In this delightful journey through the world of online jewelry, we will discover some hidden gems that will make your jewelry shopping experience a breeze. So buckle up, grab your credit card, and let’s dive in!

Ana Luisa: Affordable Jewelry That Lasts

Ana Luisa Meesh Necklace

First up, we have Ana Luisa, a brand that specializes in affordable jewelry that’s designed to last. Not only are their pieces stylish, but each one also comes with a two-year warranty. So say goodbye to snapped chains and missing stones! One of their bestsellers, the Meesh Necklace, is not only beautiful and shiny, but it’s also hypoallergenic, perfect for those of us with sensitive skin. Trust us, you’ll be showered with compliments every time you wear it. Check out our full review of Ana Luisa to see more of our favorite pieces.

Susan Alexandra: Where Whimsy Meets Jewelry

Susan Alexandra Jewelry

If you’re looking for a brand that embraces fun and whimsy, look no further than Susan Alexandra. Famous for their campy and trendy beaded handbags, they bring the same sense of playfulness to their jewelry line. From beaded fruit earrings to a make-your-own jewelry option, there’s no shortage of quirky and colorful pieces to choose from. So why blend in when you can stand out with Susan Alexandra?

BaubleBar: Quirky and Classic All in One Place

BaubleBar Gia Necklace

BaubleBar is the destination for both the trendsetters and the classic jewelry lovers. They offer a wide range of pieces, from customizable jelly slider bracelets to elegant gold-plated designs. And if you’re a super fan of Disney or the NFL, you’re in luck! BaubleBar has partnerships with both, bringing you adorable pieces like Mickey Mouse earrings or football helmet pendants. So whether you’re looking to make a statement or add a touch of sparkle to your everyday look, BaubleBar has got you covered.

Noémie: Timeless Designs and Custom Creations

Noémie Jewelry

Noémie is all about combining timeless designs with customization. Whether you’re in the market for a classic tennis bracelet or playful diamond studs, Noémie has you covered. But what really sets them apart is their custom design option. Simply describe your dream piece and budget, and their designers will create original designs for you to choose from. It’s like having your own personal jewelry designer! So if you’re looking for truly one-of-a-kind pieces, Noémie is definitely worth exploring.

Awe Inspired: Unique and Meaningful Pieces

Awe Inspired Jewelry

If you’re tired of cookie-cutter jewelry and want something truly special, Awe Inspired is your go-to brand. Their collection of goddess-inspired necklaces, featuring mythical and real-life “goddesses,” will make you feel like a queen. And the best part? These pieces are beloved by celebrities like Taylor Swift, Halle Berry, and even Meghan Markle. With their meaningful designs and surprisingly affordable prices, Awe Inspired will leave you swooning.

Quince: Minimalist Styles at Minimal Costs

Quince Jewelry

If you’re a fan of minimalist styles but don’t want to break the bank, Quince is the place for you. Their collection of solid gold jewelry starts at an incredibly affordable $50. From 14-karat gold hoops to simple stacker rings, Quince has all the dainty pieces you need to round out your jewelry collection. So why sacrifice style for cost when you can have both with Quince?

Dorsey: Red Carpet Glam at Affordable Prices

Dorsey Jewelry

Ever dreamed of rocking a sparkling diamond necklace like the ones celebrities wear on the red carpet? With Dorsey, that dream can become a reality. Their statement pieces, made from lab-grown white sapphires and plated sterling silver, give you the red carpet look without the outrageous price tag. Whether it’s a glamorous collar necklace or an elegant tennis bracelet, Dorsey has the perfect piece to make you feel like a star.

Studs: Bringing Delicate Earrings to the Forefront

Studs Earrings

If delicate earrings are your passion, then Studs is the brand for you. With a wide assortment of hoops, studs, and huggies, they have everything you need to create the perfect earscape. And the best part? Their dainty and charming charms, ranging from cowboy boots to lava lamps, add a playful touch to your look. So if you’re ready to elevate your earring game, head over to Studs and let your lobes shine!

Ring Concierge: From Engagement Rings to Everyday Luxury

Ring Concierge Jewelry

Don’t be fooled by the name; Ring Concierge offers so much more than just engagement rings. From necklaces to bracelets, this brand has it all. While the prices may be a bit higher than some of the other brands on our list, you’re paying for quality and craftsmanship. And with their lower markups compared to traditional jewelers, you can indulge in your favorite pieces without breaking the bank. So whether you’re looking for a tennis bracelet or a simple stacking ring, Ring Concierge has something that’ll catch your eye.

Montserrat: Making a Statement with Everyday Pieces

Montserrat Jewelry

For those who want to make a statement with their everyday jewelry, Montserrat is the place to go. With their collection of elegant and playful designs, you’ll find everything from enameled fruit necklaces to bejeweled statement chokers. And the best part? Most of their pieces are under $200, so you can make a statement without breaking the bank. So why blend in when you can shine bright with Montserrat?

Italic: Luxury Without the Label

Italic Jewelry

Italic is changing the game by offering luxury without the designer label. You can find timeless additions like diamond necklaces and solid gold hoops at a fraction of the price. Made in the same factories as high-end designers, Italic eliminates the middleman, allowing you to get high-quality pieces without the hefty markup. So if you want to enjoy the finer things in life without breaking the bank, give Italic a try.

Page Sargisson: Cute and Delicate Jewelry for Every Occasion

Page Sargisson Jewelry

Brooklyn-based designer Page Sargisson brings us a collection of cute and delicate pieces meant to be worn over and over again. From opal-studded evil eye necklaces to tiny stud earrings, every piece is made with love and attention to detail. And with a range of options, from opulent to affordable, Page Sargisson ensures there’s something for everyone. So why settle for ordinary when you can shine like a star with Page Sargisson?

Catbird: Delicate Rings and Transparent Sourcing

Catbird Jewelry

Known for their delicate rings and commitment to transparency, Catbird is the epitome of cool jewelry. Their collection features delicate $48 rings alongside sparkly engagement rings, perfect for any occasion. And the best part? Catbird is transparent about the source of their materials and donates a portion of their sales to organizations like the ACLU and Planned Parenthood. So if you’re looking for jewelry that’s as ethical as it is fashionable, Catbird is the place to go.

Mejuri: Everyday Luxury Made Affordable

Mejuri Jewelry

Mejuri, a Toronto-based startup, brings us a collection of jewelry made for everyday luxury. With new pieces dropping every week, there’s always something fresh to discover. Whether it’s their 14-karat gold, gold vermeil, or sterling silver pieces, Mejuri offers affordable options without compromising on quality. So treat yourself to a daily dose of luxury without breaking the bank. Check out our editor’s review of Mejuri’s pearl hoops to learn more.

AUrate: Minimalism Meets Bold Statements

AUrate Jewelry

AUrate strikes the perfect balance between minimalism and bold statements. Their collection offers both everyday pieces and standout designs, ensuring you have a well-rounded jewelry collection. Crafted in New York City, these pieces are made with 14- and 18-karat gold, AAA pearls, and ethically sourced diamonds. Plus, if you’re lucky enough to live in NYC, you can enjoy same-day delivery. So why settle for ordinary when you can go for gold with AUrate?

Soko: Ethical Fast Fashion in Jewelry Form

Soko Jewelry

Leading the way in “ethical fast fashion” is Soko, a jewelry startup that connects with independent artisans in Africa. Their innovative model brings you unique and powerful pieces, all crafted with affordable materials like brass. So not only will you be making a fashion statement, but you’ll also be making a positive social impact. With Soko, you can wear your ethics proudly.

Auvere: Luxury That Won’t Break the Bank

Auvere Jewelry

If you’re looking for top-line luxury at affordable prices, Auvere is the brand for you. Their collection of 22- and 24-karat gold jewelry offers a range of designs, from feminine to more masculine. Each piece is wrapped in beautiful designs without the hefty markup, making these investments worth every penny. So why settle for anything less than pure gold when you can shine bright with Auvere?

Ariel Gordon: Delicate Jewelry for Everyday Elegance

Ariel Gordon Jewelry

Los Angeles-based brand Ariel Gordon brings us delicate jewelry designed for everyday elegance. Their pieces are meant to be worn over and over again, transitioning seamlessly from one occasion to another. With a collection of charming animals and flowers, Ariel Gordon adds a sweet touch to your daily look. So if you value quality and durability, give Ariel Gordon a try.

The Last Line: Bold and Beautiful Jewelry

The Last Line Jewelry

For the lovers of bold and beautiful jewelry, The Last Line is the ultimate destination. With their wide range of offerings, from show-stopping rainbow pieces to chunky rings and classic gold hoops, you can make a statement no matter your style. The Last Line proves that fine jewelry can be fun and colorful, so don’t be afraid to let your personality shine through.

Gorjana: Effortless Jewelry for Effortless Style

Gorjana Jewelry

If you love effortless style, you’ll adore Gorjana. This Laguna Beach-based brand offers a range of affordable gold-plated pieces that are perfect for everyday wear. Whether you prefer simple and dainty or funky and trendy, Gorjana has it all. And if you’re feeling a bit more luxurious, their line of fine jewelry made from solid 14-karat gold and diamonds is sure to catch your eye. So why settle for ordinary when you can embody effortless style with Gorjana?

Stone and Strand: Everyday Luxury Made Accessible

Stone and Strand Jewelry

Stone and Strand is all about bringing everyday luxury within reach. They curate their own high-end jewelry collection while also featuring other like-minded brands on their site. With pieces made of 14-karat solid gold and ethically sourced diamonds and gemstones, Stone and Strand ensures that their collection is both luxurious and accessible. So if you’re on the hunt for exceptional layering rings and necklaces, look no further than Stone and Strand.

Verlas: Try Before You Buy

Verlas Jewelry

For those who can’t make up their minds, Verlas offers a unique “try-before-you-buy” experience. Their try-at-home program allows you to test replica pieces for 15 days. Once you’ve made your decision, simply choose your favorites and order the real deal made with diamonds and gold. It’s the perfect way to ensure you’re completely satisfied with your purchase. So go ahead and indulge in a little trial and sparkle with Verlas.

Vrai: Sleek and Simplified Diamond Shopping

Vrai Jewelry

Skeptical about buying diamond rings online? Vrai is here to change your mind. This downtown LA-based company only uses solid gold and Diamond Foundry diamonds, which are indistinguishable from mined diamonds and created using solar energy. Vrai’s simple and timeless pieces are perfect for minimalists and anyone who appreciates a simplified shopping experience. And if you’re in the market for wedding rings, take advantage of their free home try-on program. It takes the pressure off choosing the perfect ring and lets you focus on the love that’s in the air.

Holden: Customize Your Perfect Wedding Rings

Holden Jewelry

When it comes to wedding ring shopping, stress can quickly overshadow the joy. But not with Holden! Their simple and user-friendly customization process allows you to create rings that perfectly symbolize your love. From choosing the profile, width, and metal to adding personal engravings, every detail is tailored to your liking. And with their made-to-order rings created with 3D printing technology, you can be confident that your rings will be as unique as your love story. So say “I do” to stress-free wedding ring shopping with Holden.

Couple: Ethical Diamonds for a Lifetime of Love

Couple Jewelry

Started by a couple who found it challenging to find an ethically sourced engagement ring, Couple aims to make your wedding experience truly special. They work with lab-grown diamonds that are physically and chemically indistinguishable from mined diamonds, offering you peace of mind along with timeless beauty. With the option to engrave the rings, you can add a personal touch that will forever remind you of your love story. Start your journey together on the right foot with Couple.

Gemist: Stackable Rings Made Easy

Gemist Jewelry

Do you love the look of a finger full of stackable rings? Gemist has got you covered! Known for their wide variety of colorful and affordable options, Gemist offers a streamlined try-on process. They send you three costume rings to play with for two weeks, and if you love them, they’ll send you the custom pieces after you return the testers. With their selection of earrings, wedding bands, and engagement rings, there’s something for every jewelry lover at Gemist.

Idyl: Modular Jewelry for Endless Possibilities

Idyl Jewelry

Last but not least, we have Idyl. This brand embraces modular jewelry, allowing you to create multiple looks from a single necklace or pair of earrings. With lab-grown diamonds and traceable solid gold, Idyl brings transparency and sustainability to its collection. So if you’re looking for versatile pieces that will never go out of style, dive into the world of Idyl.

And there you have it, a whirlwind tour of the best online jewelry stores. Whether you’re lusting after delicate pieces, seeking bold statements, or looking for ethical options, these brands have you covered. So go ahead, express your personal style and shine like the jewelry lover you are!